I would choose Plymouth ,because there was no starving time like in Jamestown witch lasted three years. There was a huge meal that lasted three days longe wich we now call Thanksgiving . It meant that the Wampanoag Indians and the Pilgrims came to peace . Unlike Jamestown where they were in constant fights . The indians taught the pilgrims how to harvest crops , and hunt .The pilgrims and indians soon after Thanksgiving had a huge prade and played many games . The first three months were tough but most of the people were strong and pulled through the ice cold winters. It was one of the most successful English colonies . The Wampanoag indians help them with many things . Which lead to them having more and more people coming to the new world .